Monthly Archives: January 2010

Don’t Try To Capitalize on Downtrodden European Countries

In it’s weekly note, Roubini Global Economics (RGE) discusses four European countries that suffered more serious crises than others during the credit crisis.  In particular, the analysis notes that these countries, Iceland, Ukraine, Romania and Latvia were saved from ruin by the International Monetary Fund (IMF), but now, the politics of the IMF may be their worst enemy.  I bring this up because some market analysts have been touting opportunities in investing in countries that have been hit the hardest in the financial crisis because they should have room to go higher in the recovery.  However, this analysis points out that many risks remain, and they are not always the most obvious.

Here is the note in full with links to RGE’s website:

Greetings from RGE!

Amid the global financial crisis, several European countries faced serious economic distress and turned to external creditors, including the EU and IMF, for emergency financing. This multilateral support relieved investors and calmed worries of full-fledged balance of payment crises. Nevertheless, these economies are not out of the woods. As first noted in an RGE note in October, political developments could push loan programs off track, reigniting crisis fears. A new RGE blog post examines political risk in four countries that seem at particular risk of having their IMF programs derailed by politics: Iceland, Latvia, Romania and Ukraine. The following analysis is drawn from that blog post.

Despite Iceland’s fulfillment of official loan conditions, the next disbursements of IMF and related Nordic loans are now at risk of falling through, following the Iceland president’s veto of the the so-called Icesave bill. The bill would have amended the terms of the €3.8 billion reimbursement to the UK and Netherlands as compensation for the more than 300,000 depositors who lost savings in Icesave, the internet arm of failed Icelandic bank Landesbanki. Iceland’s parliament accepted the bill in late December, but the President vetoed it on January 5 under heavy public pressure. A quarter of the country’s electorate had signed a petition against the bill. Immediate consequences included Fitch downgrading Iceland’s sovereign debt to junk status and S&P placing it on Creditwatch with negative implications.

In Latvia, the top court ruled in December 2009 that the government violated the constitution when it cut pensions as part of austerity measures required under the US$10.5 billion EU/IMF-led loan agreement ($2.35 billion of which is being contributed by the IMF). The cabinet now has to find money to repay the pensioners, which will likely exacerbate rifts within the ruling coalition ahead of the October 2010 parliamentary elections and threaten the IMF-led bailout.

Romania’s US$26.4 billion EU/IMF-led loan program (US$17.1 billion of which is being contributed by the IMF) appears back on track after a bout of political volatility in late 2009 threatened to derail the program. Nevertheless, it would be premature to signal the all-clear. The country’s recent elections are over, the political storm has calmed, and the IMF program appears back on track. But political risk lingers. The government holds a very slim majority in parliament and the governing coalition is made up of a disparate group of parties and independents, meaning its support is very fragile. So while political turmoil may have eased in the near-term, this is unlikely to last. Loan tranches are scheduled for quarterly disbursements through March 15, 2011, and a new flare-up of political turbulence could delay or halt future loan disbursements.

In Ukraine, the IMF signaled that cooperation would resume once political tensions settle following the country’s presidential elections, the first round of which proved inconclusive this weekend, leading to a runoff vote. Yet even the final vote might not bring policy clarity. One of the two contenders, Prime Minister Tymoshenko, accused her main rival, pro-Russian opposition leader Victor Yanukovych, of planning major electoral fraud before the election. So it doesn’t seem like consensus on tough fiscal consolidation will be easily reached. Furthermore, a new president could also dissolve parliament and call for early elections in the spring, further delaying loan disbursements. In sum, Ukraine may be facing another politically turbulent and cash strapped year in 2010.

China’s 2009 GDP Grows at 8.7 Percent Clip

According to China’s National Bureau of Statistics, the country’s gross domestic product for the full-year 2009 grew 8.7 percent, including a 10.7 percent jump in the fourth quarter.  The accelerating pace of growth has sparked fears of inflation, especially given the strong fiscal stimulus provided by the government over the past 18 months.  While the consumer price index declined 0.7 percent in 2009, it was up 1.0 percent in November and 1.9 percent in December.  China will likely raise rates in 2010 to suppress potential runaway inflation, and this has implications for the economic recovery worldwide.

The following is a statement by National Bureau of Statistics Commissioner Ma Jiantang:

The year 2009 is the most difficult time for China’s economic development in the new century. In face of the severe impact brought about by the global financial crisis in a century and the most complicated domestic and international situations, the Central Party Committee and the State Council sized up the situation, made scientific decision and headed the whole nation united as one to surmount the difficulties of our time; to stick to implement the proactive fiscal policy and moderately easy monetary policy; and to fully implement and further improve the package plan targeting on tackling with the global financial crisis. All these lead to the holding back noticeable sliding of the economy, and the national economy recovered and moved toward a favorable direction.

According to preliminary estimation, the gross domestic product (GDP) for the year 2009 was 33,535.3 billion yuan, up by 8.7 percent at comparable prices, or 0.9 percentage points lower than that in the previous year. In terms of growth by quarters, it was up 6.2 percent for the first quarter, 7.9 percent growth for the second quarter, 9.1 percent for the third quarter and 10.7 percent for the last quarter. In terms of growth by sectors, the value added of the primary industry was 3,547.7 billion yuan, up by 4.2 percent; that of the secondary industry was 15,695.8 billion yuan, up by 9.5 percent; and that of the tertiary industry was 14,291.8 billion yuan, up by 8.9 percent.

I. Agricultural Production Continued to Develop Steadily with Increase in Grain Output for Consecutive Six Years. In 2009, the total output of grain reached 530.82 million tons, an increase of 0.4 percent over that in the previous year with an output increase for the sixth year. Of this total, the output of summer grain was 123.35 million tons, a year-on-year increase of 2.2 percent; the output of early rice was 33.27 million tons, a growth of 5.3 percent over that in the previous year; the output of autumn grain was 374.20 million tons, a year-on-year decline of 0.6 percent. The output of oil-bearing seeds is expected to grow around 5.0 percent and the output of sugar will drop by 9.0 percent. The output of meat maintained steady growth and the total output of meat in 2009 reached 75.09 million tons, up by 5.0 percent. Of this total, the output of pork was 48.89 million tons, up by 5.8 percent; the number of slaughtered pigs stood at 640 million, up by 5.7 percent, the total stocks of pigs were 470 million, rose by 1.5 percent.

II. Industrial Production Picked up Quarter by Quarter, Profits Made Reversed from Sharp Declining to Rising. In 2009, the value added of the industrial enterprises above the designated size was up by 11.0 percent, or 1.9 percentage points lower than that in 2008. Of which, the growth in the first quarter was 5.1 percent, that in the second quarter was 9.1 percent, 12.4 percent growth in the third quarter and 18.0 percent growth in the last quarter. Analysis on different types of enterprises showed that the value added of the state-owned and state holding enterprises went up by 6.9 percent; collective enterprises, up by 10.2 percent; share-holding enterprises, up by 13.3 percent; and 6.2 percent growth for the enterprises funded by foreign investors or investors from Hong Kong, Macao and Taiwan. The growth of the heavy industry was 11.5 percent and that of the light industry was 9.7 percent. Among the 39 industrial divisions, all witnessed growth over the previous year. In terms of different areas, the growth in eastern, central and western regions went up by 9.7 percent, 12.1 percent and 15.5 percent respectively. The production and marketing situation was good, the sales ratio was 97.67 percent for the industrial enterprises above the designated size.

In the first eleven months of 2009, the profits made by industrial enterprises above the designated size reached 2,589.1 billion yuan, up by 7.8 percent, over the same period of last year, which was 2.9 percentage points higher than that in the same period of last year. Among the 39 industrial divisions, 30 divisions registered year-on-year growth with profits.

III. Investment Continued to Grow fast, Investment in Areas Related to People’s Livelihood Speeded up Noticeably. In 2009, the total investment in fixed assets of the country reached 22,484.6 billion yuan, a year-on-year growth of 30.1 percent, with an increase of 4.6 percentage points over the previous year. Of this total, the fixed assets investment in urban areas was 19,413.9 billion yuan, up by 30.5 percent, or 4.4 percentage points higher; and that in rural areas was 3,070.7 billion yuan, up by 27.5 percent, or 6.0 percentage points higher. Of the fixed assets investment in urban areas, the growth of investment in the primary industry was 49.9 percent; that in the secondary industry was 26.8 percent and 33.0 percent for the tertiary industry. In terms of different areas, the investment in urban areas in eastern, central and western regions grew by 23.9 percent, 36.0 percent and 35.0 percent respectively. Investment in areas that related to the improvement of people’s livelihood increased by a large margin. The investment in infrastructure facilities (excluding electricity) for the whole year topped 4,191.3 billion yuan, up 44.3 percent. Of this total, the growth of investment in railway transportation was 67.5 percent; road transportation, 40.1 percent; urban public traffic, 59.7 percent; services to households and other services, 61.8 percent; education, 37.2 percent; health, social security and social welfare, 58.5 percent. The total investment in the real estate development for the year was 3,623.2 billion yuan, a growth of 16.1 percent, which was 4.8 percentage points lower than that in 2008.

IV. The Growth of Market Sales was Steady and Fast, Sales of Selected Products Increased Rapidly. In 2009, the total sales of consumer goods reached 12,534.3 billion yuan, a growth of 15.5 percent, or a real growth of 16.9 percent after deducting price factors, which was 2.1 percentage points higher than that in the previous year. Of this total, the retail sales of consumer goods in cities stood at 8,513.3 billion yuan, up 15.5 percent, while the retail sales at and below county level reached 4,021.0 billion yuan, up 15.7 percent. Grouped by different sectors, the sales by wholesale and retail businesses was 10,541.3 billion yuan, up by 15.6 percent; and that by lodging and catering industry was 1,799.8 billion yuan, up by 16.8 percent. Of the total retail sales by wholesale and retail businesses above designated size, except that of the communication equipment, the rest 20 types of commodities all registered large margin growth. Of which, the growth of clothing, shoes, hats and textiles was 18.8 percent, that of furniture, 35.5 percent and 32.3 percent growth for automobiles.

V. The Consumer Price and Producer Price Witnessed Decline for the Whole Year, Picking up Was Shown at the End of the Year. In 2009, the CPI was down by 0.7 percent. Of this total, the CPI declined by 0.9 percent in cities and down by 0.3 percent in rural areas. Grouped by categories, four of the total eight categories witnessed price rise and the rest four had declines, the prices for tobacco and liquor, went up by 1.5 percent, that of the medical care services and personal articles, up by 1.2 percent, that of food went up by 0.7 percent, and that of household appliance and maintenance services, up 0.2 percent; the prices of housing down by 3.6 percent, that of transportation and communication, down by 2.4 percent, clothing, down by 2.0 percent and 0.7 percent decrease for recreation, education, cultural articles and services. The year-on-year change of CPI in November reversed from negative one to positive one, which was up 0.6 percent in November, it was up by 1.9 percent in December. In 2009, the year-on-year change of producers’ prices for manufactured goods down by 5.4 percent, in December it was up 1.7 percent reversing the trend of declining. The purchasers’ prices for raw material, fuel and power down by 7.9 percent for the whole year; the retail prices for commodities dropped down by 1.2 percent.

VI. The Total Value of Imports and Exports Dropped in 2009, It Shifted from Declining to Rising in November. The total value of imports and exports for the whole year reached 2,207.3 billion US dollars, a drop of 13.9 percent over that in the previous year. In November, the year-on-year change of total value of imports and exports shifted from negative one to a positive one, which was up by 9.8 percent, it was up 32.7 percent in December. The total value of exports for the whole year was 1,201.7 billion US dollars, down by 16.0 percent; that of the imports was 1,005.6 billion US dollars, down by 11.2 percent; China had a trade surplus of 196.1 billion US dollars, or 99.4 billion US dollars less over that in the previous year.

VII. Urban and Rural Residents’ Income Increased Steadily, the Employment Situation was Better than Expected. In 2009, the per capita income of urban household was 18,858 yuan. Of this total, the per capita disposable income of urban residents was 17,175 yuan, up by 8.8 percent, or a real increase of 9.8 percent after deducting price factors. Of the per capita income of urban household, the growth of wage income was 9.6 percent; that of operating net income was 5.2 percent; property income, 11.6 percent, transferred income, 14.9 percent. The per capita net income of rural residents was 5,153 yuan, up by 8.2 percent over that in the previous year, or a real increase of 8.5 percent after deducting price factors. Of this total, the growth of wage income was 11.2 percent; the production operating income from the primary industry was 2.2 percent, and that from the secondary and tertiary industries was 10.0 percent; the property income was 12.9 percent and 23.1 percent growth for the transferred income. The total newly increased employment in urban areas was 9.10 million people. By the end of the year, there were 149 million rural migrant workers; it was 1.7 million people more than that at the end of the first quarter of 2009.

VIII. Money Supply Grew Rapidly, Newly Increased Credits Increased by a Large Margin. At the end of December, the broad money (M2) was 60.6 trillion yuan, it was up 27.7 percent as compared with that at the end of 2008, the growth rate was 9.9 percentage points higher over that in the previous year; the narrow money (M1) was 22.0 trillion yuan, up by 32.4 percent, or 23.3 percentage points higher; the cash in circulation (M0) was 3,824.6 billion yuan, a rise of 11.8 percent, or down by 0.9 percentage points. The amount of outstanding loans of all financial institutions was 40.0 trillion yuan, increased by 9.6 trillion yuan over that at the beginning of this year, or an increase of 4.7 trillion yuan as compared with the same period last year.

At present, the base of world economy recovery is relatively weak; there are uncertainties in domestic economic development. Facing the complex situation of coexistence of difficulties and opportunities, we should unswervingly carry out various plans set by the central government on economic work; thoroughly apply the scientific outlook of development; maintain the consistency and stability of the macro economic policy; put forth effort to enhance the pertinence and flexibility of policies; further improve the quality and efficiency of economic growth; accelerate the change of economic growth mode and the adjustment of economic structures; actively push forward reform, opening-up and independent innovation; attach importance to the improvement of people’s livelihood and maintain a harmonious and stable social climate; take both international and domestic situation into consideration and plan accordingly; and achieve a steady and fast growth of national economy.

Investor Bullishness Not Necessarily Contrarian Indicator

According to a Bank of America Merrill Lynch fund manager survey, investors are taking on above-average risk for the first time since 2006, and bullish sentiment has returned to pre-credit crisis levels.  In the bull-and-bear cycle of equity markets, high levels of bullishness are sometimes viewed as the end of a bull market rally.  But, bullishness itself is not a contrary indicator.

The survey, which included 209 fund managers around the world, revealed that average cash balances fell to 3.4 percent net, the lowest reading since mid-2007, as demand for equities grew. This figure is down substantially from 4 percent in December 2009 as investors started to become less cautious.  There has also been a sharp decline in the number of investors protecting their portfolios against a decline in the benchmark indices, with 55 percent having no protection against overall declines in the next three months compared with 48 percent in December.

Economic optimism has returned as well.  More than 60 percent of global investors think earnings will increase by at least 10 percent over the next 12 months, up from 46 percent in December, while 40 percent of investors think that operating margins will improve.

This all might sound like the kind of complacency and unwarranted optimism that would signal a market peak.  However, Bespoke Investment Group LLC points out that high levels of investor bullishness can persist for several weeks or months before a decline arrives.  In fact, Bespoke notes that most of the gains in the S&P 500 come when bullish sentiment is above 50 percent and, over the last 10 years, less than half of the S&P’s declines have occurred when bullishness is above 50 percent.  Similar results show in other indices as well.  Thus, those looking for a near-term correction in equity markets due to investor bullishness may have to wait and watch the market move higher before they get such a result.

Deleveraging is a Global Problem: McKinsey

New McKinsey research shows that the challenge of reducing total debt levels relative to GDP is a global problem that is in an early stage of development. Leverage is still very high in some sectors of several countries, including the United States. History also shows that deleveraging episodes are painful—on average lasting six to seven years—and exert a significant drag on GDP growth in the early stages.

Several elements in today’s environment—including the global nature of the crisis and sharply increasing government debt levels—suggest that deleveraging may start later and take longer this time around. These are among the findings of the recent McKinsey Global Institute (MGI) report Debt and deleveraging: The global credit bubble and its economic consequences. The report also assesses the implications for business executives, who will likely face more expensive and less available credit; regulators, who must increase the stability of the financial system going forward; and policy makers, who face a delicate balancing act in choosing between approaches to stimulate GDP growth to gently “grow” into current debt levels or to spend in ways that add to debt without significantly boosting growth, prolonging the deleveraging process and its harsh effects.

For investors, the following key points from McKinsey’s research are worth noting:

  • Leverage levels are still very high in some sectors of several countries – and this is a global problem, not just a US one.
  • To assess the sustainability of leverage, one must take a granular view using multiple sector-specific metrics. The analysis has identified ten sectors within five economies that have a high likelihood of deleveraging.
  • Empirically, a long period of deleveraging nearly always follows a major financial crisis.
  • Deleveraging episodes are painful, lasting six to seven years on average and reducing the ratio of debt to GDP by 25 percent. GDP typically contracts during the first several years and then recovers.
  • If history is a guide, many years of debt reduction are expected in specific sectors of some of the world’s largest economies, and this process will exert a significant drag on GDP growth.
  • Coping with pockets of deleveraging is also a challenge for business executives. The process portends a prolonged period in which credit is less available and more costly, altering the viability of some of business models and changing the attractiveness of different types of investments. In historic episodes, private investment was often quite low for the duration of deleveraging. Today, the household sectors of several countries have a high likelihood of deleveraging. If this happens, consumption growth will likely be slower than the pre-crisis trend, and spending patterns will shift. Consumer-facing businesses have already seen a shift in spending toward value-oriented goods and away from luxury goods, and this new pattern may persist while households repair their balance sheets. Business leaders will need flexibility to respond to such shifts.

This does not mean that equity markets are going to crash again, as some are predicting.  However, government bond markets hold the keys to economic recovery.  If they refuse to fund the outsized debt many countries are carrying and will be adding to, then we could see another credit crisis, this time sparked by sovereign defaults and rating downgrades, and an accompanying market collapse.  So, the market crash predictors may not necessarily be wrong, but they also cannot pinpoint when such an event will happen and whether and how much higher the markets may rise in the meantime.

Thus, investors should prepare for lower returns than what markets have provided since World War II.  Investors need to be cautious and judicious about which sectors and companies to allocate their investments.  Rather than trying to time a significant correction or worse, it is better to simply mitigate risk, while seeking a reasonable return. Stocks that come with higher dividend yields will likely be in demand, even though, thus far, they have largely been ignored in favor of riskier assets.

CMBS Delinquencies Will Not Peak Until 2010: Fitch

In commenting on the latest Loan Delinquency Index (LDI), Fitch Ratings Managing Director Mary MacNeill said U.S. commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) delinquencies may not peak until 2012, despite the fact that they have already risen almost five times from one year ago.  According to Fitch’s LDI, the U.S. CMBS delinquency rate closed 2009 at 4.71 percent.

“An increased amount of loans are coming due over the next two years that will result in delinquencies possibly peaking at 12%,” MacNeill said.  Fitch’s surveillance criteria reflect a forward looking view of performance.  Therefore, the current ratings on CMBS transactions recently reviewed by Fitch incorporate significantly higher delinquency rates.

Of the five main property types, each has seen an increase in delinquencies of over 195 percent since December 2008, ranging from multifamily with 196 percent increase, to hotel, with a 1,175 percent increase. Delinquency rates for these properties are as follows (along with total dollars delinquent versus total dollars delinquent as of December 2008):

—Office: 2.66 percent ($3.9 billion vs. $603.5 million);
—Hotel: 9.13 percent ($4.6 billion vs. $363.7 million);
—Retail: 4.25 percent ($5.7 billion vs. $1.2 billion);
—Multifamily: 7.54 percent ($5 billion vs. $1.6 billion);
—Industrial: 3.57 percent ($851.3 million vs. $186.2 million).

There are currently 25 delinquent loans greater than $100 million, compared to four in December 2008. An increased number of loans with larger balances were securitized in 2006 and 2007, when underwriting was most aggressive. Given the restricted lending environment, Fitch expects delinquencies and maturity defaults of these loans to be a significant contributor to the future Index.

Due to the increased volume alongside weaker underwriting parameters for later vintages, defaults increased significantly from the end of 2008. The four most-recent vintages have gone from representing just over half of delinquencies by balance to over 75 percent of the total at the end of December. They have the following delinquency rates (along with total dollars delinquent versus total dollars delinquent as of December 2008):

—2005: 3.16 percent ($2.4 billion vs. $420.1 million)
—2006: 5.11 percent ($5.6 billion vs. $1.1 billion);
—2007: 5.22 percent ($8.1 billion vs. $631.9 million);
—2008: 7.33 percent ($312.8 million vs. $236.5 million).

At this time, vintage delinquencies remain somewhat proportional to each vintage’s contribution to the Fitch universe. However, Fitch expects continued cash flow stress will lead to increased delinquencies among these vintages. The percent of delinquent loans versus the percent of the Fitch-rated universe are as follows:

—2005: 11.19 percent v. 16.68 percent;
—2006: 26.04 percent v. 24.01 percent;
—2007: 37.50 percent v. 33.80 percent;
—2008: 1.45 percent v. 0.93 percent.

Fitch’s delinquency index includes 2,143 loans totaling $21.6 billion of the Fitch rated universe of approximately 42,000 loans comprising $457.5 billion that are at least 60 days delinquent or in foreclosure. The LDI excludes Fitch-rated loans that are 30 to 59 days delinquent, which currently total $7.2 billion, a decrease from $7.5 billion one month prior (Extended Stay America was re-classified as 60 days delinquent after being only 30 in November).